Car Dyke – ABC News PodCast

Summary

The book ‘The Car Dyke LiDAR Atlas’ presents a thorough investigation of the Car Dyke, a large ancient waterway in Britain. Using LiDAR technology, the author argues that the Dyke is much older than previously thought, dating back to the Mesolithic/Neolithic periods, and was likely used for transportation and water management rather than simply as a Roman drainage channel or defensive barrier. The book features detailed maps and analysis of the Dyke’s construction and course, including insights into the surrounding landscape and archaeological finds, to support the author’s conclusions.

Car Dyke Transcript

Welcome in deep divers ready to get our hands dirty.

Always up for a challenge, especially if it involves rewriting history.

Today we’re diving headfirst into the heart of eastern England.

Sounds intriguing. What’s on the agenda? Roman ruins, hidden treasure.

Even better, we’re tackling a seemingly unassuming ditch known as Car Dyke

A ditch. You’ve piqued my curiosity. There’s got to be more to it than meets the eye.

Oh, absolutely. This isn’t just any ditch car. Dyke has been hiding in plain sight for centuries, mislabeled as just another Roman canal.

I’m sensing a butt coming,

But thanks to some seriously cool tech. Lidar, our car dyke secrets are finally coming to light

Lidar for our listeners who aren’t familiar, it’s like giving archaeologist X-ray vision, right? Seeing beneath the surface without even lifting a shovel.

You got it. And that’s where Robert John Langdon’s work comes in his Car Dyke Atlas uses lidar to paint a whole new picture of this ancient waterway.

Okay. I’m hooked. We’ve got cutting edge technology and a fresh perspective on what we thought we knew. Let’s dive in.

Let’s start with the biggest bombshell car Dyke’s actual length. We used to think it was around 85 miles long. Not too shabby, right?

Impressive for sure.

Hold on to your hats, because LiDAR revealed it’s actually a whopping 103 miles long.

Well, that’s longer than any other known dyke in Britain. Talk about a game changer.

Yeah,

Suddenly we’re not talking about a local project. This suggests a level of planning and coordination that makes you rethink everything.

And that’s just the beginning. Remember those assumptions about car dyke being Roman? Well, LiDAR revealed something interesting. Instead of those ruler straight lines. The Romans loved some sections. Let’s just say they get a little. Wiggly. Not exactly the precision engineering we associate with Rome.

So not just longer, but potentially much older. This is where things get really interesting.

These wiggly sections, what makes them so special?

They often line up perfectly with ancient shorelines and natural springs. Features you wouldn’t know about without Lidar’s ability to see underground. It suggests construction happened when the Fens were a much wetter, wilder place.

So instead of battling the landscape like the Romans might have, these early builders worked with nature using their knowledge of water flow and natural springs to their advantage. Talk about ingenuity. It really highlights their adaptability and deep understanding of the environment.

It’s like comparing two completely different engineering philosophies, reflecting not just changing needs, but how technology evolved over thousands of years.

Absolutely. And that contrast is crystal clear when you look at Langdon’s maps, the early sections hugging the high ground, ensuring that natural flow from the springs,

And then the later Roman sections just slicing straight through.

It’s like they said, we’re the Romans, we build in straight lines.

But what’s amazing is how those early sections might have worked, just like modern canals, but without using locks, they relied on those natural gradients and carefully chosen routes to manage the flow of water.

Now that’s some clever engineering. Speaking of which, how did LiDAR help uncover these subtle differences in construction?

Imagine looking at an aerial photo of a dense forest. You see trees, right? But not what’s below. LiDAR strips away that canopy. It revealed subtle changes in elevation and vegetation that hinted at these different construction phases.

So it’s like they left us a hidden message written in the very landscape itself, and we finally have the tools to decipher it.

We’ve got this massive waterway, potentially pre-Roman, showing a deep understanding of water management. This can’t just be about irrigation, right? What was its purpose?

That’s the million dollar question. And it forces us to rethink our assumptions about life in prehistoric Britain. If these early sections of Car Dyke really do predate the Romans,

Which the lidar suggests they do.

Exactly. Then we’re talking about a society far more advanced and interconnected than we ever imagined.

This wasn’t just a weekend project. It was a mammoth undertaking requiring incredible coordination and collaboration, and that just wasn’t thought possible for people of that era.

It really flips the script on how we view them, doesn’t it? They weren’t just surviving, they were thriving. And Car Dyke, that just might be the key to understanding how.

############################ (Car Dyke – ABC News PodCast)

Car Dyke - ABC News PodCast
(Car Dyke – ABC News PodCast)

We’re back. Deep divers. Did you catch your breath yet? After that last revelation?

Honestly, I’m still wrapping my head around it. It really makes you wonder what else we’ve missed when it comes to our ancient ancestors.

Right? And get this, the plot thickens. It turns out Car Dyke might challenge one of our biggest assumptions about ancient dykes in general.

Okay. I’m listening. What assumption are we shattering today?

Well, we usually think of these huge ditches as, you know, defensive barriers. Like drawing a line in the sand. You stay over there. We’ll stay over here.

Yeah, like a giant keep out sign. But Car Dyke doesn’t quite fit that mould, does it?

Not one bit. This network, especially with those older sections connecting to lost shorelines. And get this paleo channels, they’re basically ancient dried up riverbeds. Points to something way more interesting.

So instead of walls, we’re talking about prehistoric highways. Like a way to actually connect with other settlements.

Bingo. Think about it. Moving goods, sharing ideas, all made possible by an intricate network of waterways. Long before the Romans ever marched in with their straight roads, the Britons were cruising along these waterways. And speaking of moving things,

You’re thinking about Stonehenge, aren’t you?

Busted. But seriously, those massive stones, Avebury, all of that moving them has always been a logistical head scratcher. Could Car Dyke hold the answer?

It’s a mind blowing thought, isn’t it? Imagine, instead of back breakingly dragging those stones over land, they were floating them along this intricate waterway system. So much more efficient and less disruptive. Picture a flotilla of prehistoric boats navigating these channels, those iconic stones on board not just cargo, but symbols of shared beliefs, maybe even religious ideas. It’s a completely different picture of prehistoric Britain, isn’t it?

Completely. It makes you realise how much we may have underestimated them. But okay, before we get too carried away, let’s bring it back to the data. Langdon doesn’t just stop it, at Lidar. He goes full on detective, analysing the objects found along car dyke. What he find.

This is where the statistical analysis comes in. Langdon looked at how likely it was to find such a large cluster of artefacts from specific eras. The Mesolithic, Neolithic and Bronze Age all along the Dyke.

Don’t keep us in suspense.

Let’s just say the results were, statistically speaking, through the roof. Way too many artifacts to be some happy coincidence.

So not just a few random things people dropped, but evidence of something much bigger going on.

Precisely. It strongly indicates that stretches of car dyke were hives of activity long before the Romans showed up.

Okay, so now we have this picture. A huge ancient network of waterways possibly used for trade transportation. Who knows what else. Then enter the Romans, Masters of engineering and straight lines. What did they make of this already existing infrastructure?

That’s the fascinating part. As ingenious as the Romans were, they were also incredibly practical. They saw the brilliance in those wiggly, meandering waterways, how they follow the natural lay of the land. And they rolled with it.

So a bit of where the Romans, we do things our way, but also a touch of, hmm, these prehistoric folks were on to something.

Exactly. They incorporated the preexisting knowledge into their own plans. You can actually see this in Car Dyke today. Some sections are those laser street Roman roads bear hair waterways, while others wiggle and wind following those ancient, more organic roots.

Talk about a fusion of styles. It speaks to Roman ingenuity, but also a respect for the people who came before. But this begs the question why were the Romans so drawn to Car Dyke  in the first place? Was it just strategic, or was there more to it? Langdon suggests this waterway may have been a key factor in the economy back then. Could we go as far as to call it a prehistoric economic engine?

##############################(Car Dyke – ABC News PodCast)

(Car Dyke - ABC News PodCast)

So we’re back. Last we left off, we were trying to wrap our heads around car dyke being this, well, prehistoric economic powerhouse, a bit of a bold statement that you think maybe, but think about it. What are the key ingredients for a thriving economy? You need resources, sure, but also the means to move them around, to connect, to exchange. Not just goods, but ideas. And that’s where car dyke comes in.

So it wasn’t just about moving stuff from point A to point B, but actually creating a system for growth and innovation.

Exactly. Car Dyke wasn’t just a ditch. It was an artery, a network of waterways breathing life into these settlements that might have otherwise been isolated. Imagine the possibilities. Suddenly you have specialized skills. Trade routes, a breeding ground for new ideas. All thanks to this intricate water system.

Okay, I’m starting to see the bigger picture, but what evidence did Langdon find that really supports this prehistoric Silicon Valley theory?

Well, he points to the clusters of specific artifacts found along car dyke tools, pottery, remnants of early metalworking, all concentrated in ways that suggest something beyond just your average everyday life.

More like specialized workshops, right? Taking advantage of the waterway, both to get their raw materials and then ship out whatever they created.

Precisely. And it makes you look at those wiggly sections, those seemingly less efficient paths in a whole new light.

They weren’t just following the terrain, they were strategically connecting these hubs of activity.

Exactly. Plus, we can’t forget the sheer scale of this thing. Building and maintaining 103 mile waterway, even with prehistoric tools, would have taken massive coordination and organization.

We’re talking next level project management, leadership, planning, resource allocation. It boggles the mind, not to mention the exchange of knowledge that must have happened along the way.

Right? Think about all those different groups coming together, each with their own skills and knowledge. That kind of collaboration, that cross-pollination of ideas, it’s the perfect recipe for innovation.

So not just an economic engine, but a melting pot of ideas and innovation. It’s amazing to think that this simple ditch might hold the key to understanding how complex societies developed in prehistoric Britain.

It really makes you wonder what else is still out there, hidden just beneath the surface, waiting for us to uncover it,

And to think all it took was a fresh perspective, a healthy dose of curiosity, and of course, the magic of Lidar.

Who knows what other mysteries are waiting to be revealed

To all you deep divers tuning in. If this exploration of Car Dyke has taught us anything, it’s that history is full of surprises. So keep questioning, keep exploring. And who knows, maybe you’ll make the next big discovery. Until next time, happy digging.

Car Dyke the eBook with be available from www,prehistoric-britain.co.uk website from 1st November 2024 price £4.95.

(Car Dyke – ABC News PodCast)

Further Reading

For information about British Prehistory, visit www.prehistoric-britain.co.uk for the most extensive archaeology blogs and investigations collection, including modern LiDAR reports.  This site also includes extracts and articles from the Robert John Langdon Trilogy about Britain in the Prehistoric period, including titles such as The Stonehenge Enigma, Dawn of the Lost Civilisation and the ultimate proof of Post Glacial Flooding and the landscape we see today.

Robert John Langdon has also created a YouTube web channel with over 100 investigations and video documentaries to support his classic trilogy (Prehistoric Britain). He has also released a collection of strange coincidences that he calls ‘13 Things that Don’t Make Sense in History’ and his recent discovery of a lost Stone Avenue at Avebury in Wiltshire called ‘Silbury Avenue – the Lost Stone Avenue’.

Langdon has also produced a series of ‘shorts’, which are extracts from his main body of books:

The Ancient Mariners

Stonehenge Built 8300 BCE

Old Sarum

Prehistoric Rivers

Dykes ditches and Earthworks

Echoes of Atlantis

Homo Superior

Other Blogs

[sitemap_posts]

Car Dyke – North Section

This is a primary report of the first LiDAR mapping of Car Dyke in Lincolnshire

Introduction

Car Dyke is one of the most enigmatic and intriguing remnants of Roman engineering in Britain.  Stretching across the Fens of Eastern England, this ancient waterway has puzzled historians, archaeologists, and enthusiasts for centuries.  Theories about its purpose and origin are as varied as they are compelling, reflecting the complexities of interpreting ancient structures without definitive historical records.  This introduction aims to present a comprehensive overview of Car Dyke, encompassing both past and current theories regarding its use and origin.

Car Dyke: A Brief Description

Car Dyke runs for approximately 85 miles (137 kilometres) from Waterbeach in Cambridgeshire to the River Witham near Lincoln.  Its construction is attributed to the Roman period, specifically around the 1st or 2nd century AD.  The Dyke consists of a broad, shallow ditch with accompanying banks, a typical feature of Roman civil engineering, yet its exact function remains a matter of debate.

Early Theories: Navigational and Defensive Purposes

The earliest theories about Car Dyke’s purpose centred around its potential use as a navigational canal.  Some scholars suggested that the Romans constructed it to facilitate the movement of goods and troops across the Fenlands, which were notoriously difficult to traverse due to their marshy nature.  This theory aligns with the Romans’ known prowess in building canals and other hydraulic structures throughout their empire.

Another prevalent early theory posited that Car Dyke served a defensive purpose.  Given the strategic importance of controlling the Fenlands, it was speculated that the Dyke might have been part of a broader military defence network.  The presence of Roman forts and settlements along its route lends some credence to this idea, suggesting that the Dyke could have been a boundary or a means to control movement through the region.

(Car Dyke - North Section)

Our Research

We have now sucessfully mapped the northern section of Car Dyke and located all the findings from periods from Mesolithic Period to modern times. Our objective is to discover or confirm the construction date of the Dyke and its function.

(Car Dyke - North Section)
Fens

The first aspect of the maps show that Car Dyke ‘hugs’ the raised shorelines of the Fen Area. This is in contrast to the modern and some Roman drainage ditches.

(Car Dyke - North Section)
Car Dyke – Profile

Locks and Water Management

One of the most striking anomalies observed in the Car Dyke is the varying elevation profile along its course. Contrary to what might be expected from a Roman engineering project, the dyke does not maintain a flat or consistent gradient. In fact, in some sections, the elevation fluctuates by as much as 4 meters (14 feet) without the apparent use of locks to regulate water flow.

This irregularity raises intriguing questions about the design and function of the Car Dyke. Historically, Greek engineers were pioneers in using canal locks, employing them to manage water levels in the Ancient Suez Canal as early as the 3rd century BC. Similarly, under Emperor Trajan, the Romans utilised sluice gates to control water flow at the entrance to the Red Sea, extending the canal south to what is now Cairo to improve water inflow.

The possibility that the Romans might have used ancient pound locks to manage height differences in canals has been proposed by several scholars. These locks would have allowed for regulating water levels and bridging elevation gaps, much like modern lock systems. However, the absence of clear archaeological evidence for such structures in the Car Dyke—or elsewhere in Roman Britain—leaves this hypothesis unresolved.

Given the significant elevation changes along the Car Dyke, the lack of any visible lock mechanisms suggests alternative explanations must be considered. It’s possible that natural springs or other water sources were strategically utilised to maintain water levels or that the dyke served a different purpose altogether, one that did not require precise water level management.

The question of whether ancient pound locks were used in the Car Dyke remains one of the many mysteries surrounding this ancient structure. Without concrete archaeological evidence, the debate is likely to continue. However, the abnormal elevation profile is a critical factor that must be addressed in any comprehensive analysis of the Car Dyke’s construction and function. As we delve deeper into the investigation, understanding how these variations in height were managed will be crucial to unravelling the true nature of this enigmatic alleged Roman legacy.

(Car Dyke - North Section)
Wibbly-Wobbly pathway is not of Roman design

Dyke Design

In examining the northern section of the Car Dyke, we observe two markedly different design patterns, each suggesting a distinct approach to engineering. The first pattern, characterised by a “wibbly-wobbly” alignment, closely follows the contours of higher land formations and hugs the shoreline. In contrast, the second design, which traverses the low-lying marshlands (indicated in blue), features the straight, linear precision typically associated with Roman engineering.

This stark contrast in design raises the possibility of looking at two different techniques, potentially indicative of two separate historical periods and civilisations at work. The “wibbly-wobbly” design, with its organic, meandering course, suggests a construction that prioritised the natural landscape, possibly indicating a pre-Roman origin. This approach aligns with a more ancient engineering practice, where the path of the dyke would have been dictated by the topography and the need to follow natural water sources or higher ground to avoid flooding.

The more uniform and linear sections of the dyke, on the other hand, are characteristic of Roman engineering. The Romans emphasised straight lines and efficient, purposeful design, often cutting across landscapes with little regard for natural obstacles. This technique is evident in their roads, aqueducts, and canals, where functionality and directness were paramount.

Given these observations, it is logical to hypothesise that the Car Dyke in its “wibbly-wobbly” form may have been an earlier construction, later adapted or reused by the Romans. This scenario suggests a continuum of engineering efforts, where the Romans recognised the utility of an existing structure and modified or extended it according to their own methods and needs.

Roman Roads and car dyke
Car Dyke and Roman Roads that are Straight

This theory of two distinct periods of construction is supported by the duality in the dyke’s design: the original, meandering path possibly built by an earlier civilisation and the later, more systematic Roman modifications. The reuse of earlier infrastructure by the Romans was not uncommon; they often incorporated and improved upon existing works, blending local traditions with their engineering principles.

While this hypothesis offers a compelling narrative, it remains speculative without further archaeological evidence. The precise dating of the different sections and the identification of specific construction techniques and materials will be crucial in confirming whether the “wibbly-wobbly” sections indeed predate the Roman modifications.

If this interpretation holds, it would provide valuable insights into the history of the region, illustrating a timeline where the Car Dyke evolved from a local engineering solution to a component of the expansive Roman infrastructure network. This layered history would highlight the Romans’ pragmatic approach to utilising existing resources and underscore the continuity and adaptation of engineering practices across different civilisations in Britain.

In conclusion, the northern section of the Car Dyke, with its dual design characteristics, likely reflects two distinct historical phases. The “wibbly-wobbly” sections suggest an earlier, possibly pre-Roman origin, later integrated into the Roman landscape through their characteristic straight-line construction. This scenario offers a fascinating glimpse into the interaction between different cultures and the evolution of engineering practices over time. Further research and excavation will be essential to validate this theory and fully understand the complex history of the Car Dyke.

The Maths and Proof of Concept

End of The Northern Section

This is the end of the Northern section and the Lincolnshire database. It allows us to examine the number of artefacts found and the probability that they were in use during this period. This probability is calculated by understanding the frequency of finds on Average over the entire county.  Consequently, this is the collective number of artefacts found in Lincolnshire:

To calculate the prior probabilities for each period based on the total number of finds in Lincoln, we first calculate the total number of finds across all periods:

Step 1: Total Number of Finds

Total Finds=13,723(Roman)+8,994(Medieval)+5,619(Post Medieval)+1,680(Early Medieval)+2,451(Iron Age)+2,091(Neolithic)+634(Mesolithic)+980(Bronze Age)=36,172\text{Total Finds} = 13,723 (\text{Roman}) + 8,994 (\text{Medieval}) + 5,619 (\text{Post Medieval}) + 1,680 (\text{Early Medieval}) + 2,451 (\text{Iron Age}) + 2,091 (\text{Neolithic}) + 634 (\text{Mesolithic}) + 980 (\text{Bronze Age}) = 36,172Total Finds=13,723(Roman)+8,994(Medieval)+5,619(Post Medieval)+1,680(Early Medieval)+2,451(Iron Age)+2,091(Neolithic)+634(Mesolithic)+980(Bronze Age)=36,172

Step 2: Calculate Prior Probabilities

Divide the number of finds for each period by the total number of finds:

P(Roman)=13,72336,172≈0.3794P(\text{Roman}) = \frac{13,723}{36,172} \approx 0.3794P(Roman)=36,17213,723​≈0.3794 P(Medieval)=8,99436,172≈0.2487P(\text{Medieval}) = \frac{8,994}{36,172} \approx 0.2487P(Medieval)=36,1728,994​≈0.2487 P(Post Medieval)=5,61936,172≈0.1554P(\text{Post Medieval}) = \frac{5,619}{36,172} \approx 0.1554P(Post Medieval)=36,1725,619​≈0.1554 P(Early Medieval)=1,68036,172≈0.0465P(\text{Early Medieval}) = \frac{1,680}{36,172} \approx 0.0465P(Early Medieval)=36,1721,680​≈0.0465 P(Iron Age)=2,45136,172≈0.0678P(\text{Iron Age}) = \frac{2,451}{36,172} \approx 0.0678P(Iron Age)=36,1722,451​≈0.0678 P(Neolithic)=2,09136,172≈0.0578P(\text{Neolithic}) = \frac{2,091}{36,172} \approx 0.0578P(Neolithic)=36,1722,091​≈0.0578 P(Mesolithic)=63436,172≈0.0175P(\text{Mesolithic}) = \frac{634}{36,172} \approx 0.0175P(Mesolithic)=36,172634​≈0.0175 P(Bronze Age)=98036,172≈0.0271P(\text{Bronze Age}) = \frac{980}{36,172} \approx 0.0271P(Bronze Age)=36,172980​≈0.0271

Summary of Prior Probabilities:

  • Roman: 0.3794
  • Medieval: 0.2487
  • Post Medieval: 0.1554
  • Early Medieval: 0.0465
  • Iron Age: 0.0678
  • Neolithic: 0.0578
  • Mesolithic: 0.0175
  • Bronze Age: 0.0271

Step 1: Define Prior Probabilities

Using the prior probabilities:

  • Roman: P(HRoman)=0.3794P(H_{\text{Roman}}) = 0.3794P(HRoman​)=0.3794
  • Bronze Age: P(HBronze Age)=0.0271P(H_{\text{Bronze Age}}) = 0.0271P(HBronze Age​)=0.0271
  • Neolithic/Mesolithic: P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic)=0.0753P(H_{\text{Neolithic/Mesolithic}}) = 0.0753P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic​)=0.0753

Step 2: Evidence Likelihoods Based on Local Data

Given the distribution of finds:

  • Roman: P(ERoman∣HRoman)=24132≈0.1818P(E_{\text{Roman}}|H_{\text{Roman}}) = \frac{24}{132} \approx 0.1818P(ERoman​∣HRoman​)=13224​≈0.1818
  • Bronze Age: P(EBronze Age∣HBronze Age)=47132≈0.3561P(E_{\text{Bronze Age}}|H_{\text{Bronze Age}}) = \frac{47}{132} \approx 0.3561P(EBronze Age​∣HBronze Age​)=13247​≈0.3561
  • Neolithic/Mesolithic: P(ENeolithic/Mesolithic∣HNeolithic/Mesolithic)=61132≈0.4621P(E_{\text{Neolithic/Mesolithic}}|H_{\text{Neolithic/Mesolithic}}) = \frac{61}{132} \approx 0.4621P(ENeolithic/Mesolithic​∣HNeolithic/Mesolithic​)=13261​≈0.4621

Step 3: Apply Bayes’ Theorem

Posterior Probability for Roman:

P(HRoman∣E)=0.1818×0.3794P(E)=0.0689P(E)P(H_{\text{Roman}}|E) = \frac{0.1818 \times 0.3794}{P(E)} = \frac{0.0689}{P(E)}P(HRoman​∣E)=P(E)0.1818×0.3794​=P(E)0.0689​

Posterior Probability for Bronze Age:

P(HBronze Age∣E)=0.3561×0.0271P(E)=0.0097P(E)P(H_{\text{Bronze Age}}|E) = \frac{0.3561 \times 0.0271}{P(E)} = \frac{0.0097}{P(E)}P(HBronze Age​∣E)=P(E)0.3561×0.0271​=P(E)0.0097​

Posterior Probability for Neolithic/Mesolithic:

P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic∣E)=0.4621×0.0753P(E)=0.0348P(E)P(H_{\text{Neolithic/Mesolithic}}|E) = \frac{0.4621 \times 0.0753}{P(E)} = \frac{0.0348}{P(E)}P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic​∣E)=P(E)0.4621×0.0753​=P(E)0.0348​

Step 4: Normalize the Posterior Probabilities

Sum of the calculated values for normalisation:

P(E)=0.0689+0.0097+0.0348≈0.1134P(E) = 0.0689 + 0.0097 + 0.0348 \approx 0.1134P(E)=0.0689+0.0097+0.0348≈0.1134

Now, calculate the normalised posterior probabilities:

  • Roman:

P(HRoman∣E)=0.06890.1134≈0.6074P(H_{\text{Roman}}|E) = \frac{0.0689}{0.1134} \approx 0.6074P(HRoman​∣E)=0.11340.0689​≈0.6074

  • Bronze Age:

P(HBronze Age∣E)=0.00970.1134≈0.0855P(H_{\text{Bronze Age}}|E) = \frac{0.0097}{0.1134} \approx 0.0855P(HBronze Age​∣E)=0.11340.0097​≈0.0855

  • Neolithic/Mesolithic:

P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic∣E)=0.03480.1134≈0.3069P(H_{\text{Neolithic/Mesolithic}}|E) = \frac{0.0348}{0.1134} \approx 0.3069P(HNeolithic/Mesolithic​∣E)=0.11340.0348​≈0.3069

Analysis and Interpretation:

  • Neolithic/Mesolithic: The higher frequency of finds in this period significantly increases its posterior probability to approximately 30.69%, which is quite substantial.
  • Roman: Despite having fewer finds in this area, the Roman period still has a high posterior probability due to its higher prior, but it is now only about 60.74%.
  • Bronze Age: The probability for the Bronze Age period remains lower at approximately 8.55%.

Conclusion:

The calculated probabilities show a more balanced view, with the Roman period still favoured but with a much stronger case for the Mesolithic/Neolithic period. This suggests that while Roman use of the Dyke is still likely, the Mesolithic/Neolithic period also holds significant importance, potentially indicating earlier use or occupation before the Romans.

Langdon Mathematics

While Bayesian theory often yields definitive results, its accuracy can be compromised due to its dependence on subjective prior assumptions, which may only sometimes reflect reality. If these priors are not well-chosen or are based on incomplete or biased information, the resulting analysis might be misleading.

Therefore, relying solely on Bayesian methods without considering the variability and complexity of archaeological data could lead to conclusions that only partially capture the nuances of the actual distribution of artefacts. My method, which focuses on spatial analysis and empirical data, addresses these limitations.

My approach to calculating finds would differ significantly. First, I would define the area where artefacts could be discovered—using Lincolnshire as a reference due to its comprehensive archaeological data. By doing so, we can estimate the expected number of artefacts per square meter of Lincolnshire land, offering a more objective and spatially grounded method for understanding artefact distribution.

As IA reports:

To calculate the percentage likelihood of finding an artefact from each period in a single square meter of Lincolnshire, we can follow these steps:

Step 1: Determine the Area of Lincolnshire

  • Area of Lincolnshire: Approximately 6,959 square kilometres (6,959,000,000 square meters).

Step 2: Calculate the Find Density

For each period, calculate the density of finds per square meter by dividing the total number of finds by the area of Lincolnshire.

​

Step 3: Calculate the Likelihood for Each Period

  1. Roman:

Likelihood: 0.000156%

  • Neolithic:

Likelihood: 0.000011%

  • Mesolithic:

Likelihood: 0.000004%

  • Bronze Age:

Likelihood: 0.000003%

Summary of Likelihoods in order of expectation:

  • Roman: 0.000156%
  • Medieval: 0.000129%
  • Post Medieval: 0.000081%
  • Early Medieval: 0.000024%
  • Iron Age: 0.000021%
  • Neolithic: 0.000011%
  • Mesolithic: 0.000004%
  • Bronze Age: 0.000003%

These percentages represent the likelihood of finding an artefact from each period in a square meter of Lincolnshire. Given the extensive activity during that time, the highest is for the Roman period, just marginally ahead of the Medieval period.

We now need to look at the search area (63 miles of the Northern End of Car Dyke) as listing on the LiDAR maps in the previous section of the book.  We must first calculate the total search area in square metres, count the number of finding within this area, and then compare against the expected number.

Summary of Expected Finds:

  • Roman: 15.83 artefacts
  • Medieval: 13.07 artefacts
  • Post Medieval: 8.19 artefacts
  • Early Medieval: 2.44 artefacts
  • Iron Age: 2.17 artefacts
  • Neolithic: 1.07 artefacts
  • Unknown: 0.59 artefacts
  • Modern: 0.50 artefacts
  • Mesolithic: 0.36 artefacts
  • Bronze Age: 0.34 artefacts

Summary of Items Found:

  • Mesolithic/Neolithic: 61 finds
  • Bronze Age: 47 finds
  • Roman: 24 finds

Calculate the Odds of This Kind of Find

For each period, the odds ratio of finding this many artefacts compared to the expected finds:

Step 4: Interpret the Results

  • Mesolithic/Neolithic: A massive 5589.72% increase and an odds ratio of 57.01 suggest significant activity during this period, far beyond what was expected.
  • Bronze Age: An even higher increase of 13723.53% and an odds ratio of 138.24 indicate the area was very important during the Bronze Age.
  • Roman: A modest 51.60% increase with an odds ratio of 1.52 suggests Roman activity, but not as dominant as the earlier periods.

Conclusion

The very high percentage increases and odds ratios for the Mesolithic/Neolithic and Bronze Age periods strongly suggest that the Car Dyke area was occupied and actively used during these times, with significant archaeological activity that exceeds what would be expected based on general Lincolnshire data. While still represented, the Roman period is less prominent in this area compared to the earlier periods.

This confirms other Dyke surveys such as Offa’s and Wansdyke that also show design (wibbly-wobbly) in construction attributed to the builders seeking natural springs rather than a direct line of route to maintain water levels which were achieved at a later date in history by locks.

Further Reading

For information about British Prehistory, visit www.prehistoric-britain.co.uk for the most extensive archaeology blogs and investigations collection, including modern LiDAR reports.  This site also includes extracts and articles from the Robert John Langdon Trilogy about Britain in the Prehistoric period, including titles such as The Stonehenge Enigma, Dawn of the Lost Civilisation and the ultimate proof of Post Glacial Flooding and the landscape we see today.

Robert John Langdon has also created a YouTube web channel with over 100 investigations and video documentaries to support his classic trilogy (Prehistoric Britain). He has also released a collection of strange coincidences that he calls ‘13 Things that Don’t Make Sense in History’ and his recent discovery of a lost Stone Avenue at Avebury in Wiltshire called ‘Silbury Avenue – the Lost Stone Avenue’.

Langdon has also produced a series of ‘shorts’, which are extracts from his main body of books:

The Ancient Mariners

Stonehenge Built 8300 BCE

Old Sarum

Prehistoric Rivers

Dykes ditches and Earthworks

Echoes of Atlantis

Homo Superior

Other Blogs

[sitemap_posts]